Replace Pool Pump Motor Or Whole Pump? (Answered)

It’s important to understand what’s the best course of action when it comes to managing a pool and getting the equipment in good shape.

A lot of mistakes can be made when deciding which part of the pool to replace and that’s why doing your homework is a must. It’s the only way to make sure you are not ending up ruining how the pool functions because that can happen from time to time.

You will want to figure out whether or not to replace a pool pump motor or the whole pump.

Replacing a pool pump motor is less expensive, requires less effort, but can only be done when the pump housing is intact. On the other hand, replacing the whole pump is more costly but is far more energy-efficient and longer-lasting.

The best option is to go with what your budget allows you to do.

For those who don’t think the cost is going to hinder them, it’s best to replace the whole pool pump. You are going to see much better results by doing this and it’s going to offer peace of mind as well.

Here is a look at four factors when deciding between replacing a pool pump motor or the whole pump.

Comparing Replacing Pool Pump Motor Or Whole Pump

1. Cost

For a lot of pool owners, there is one factor that is going to decide which direction they end up going in.

If you are someone that has money to spend on the replacement, it is best to move forward by changing the entire pump.

The reason you are going to want to do this is it will take care of the entire setup. You will not have to worry about the pool pump housing or any other part that is going to age out over time. Instead, you are going to have a brand-new pool pump in place right away.

This is a lot better for those who are just hoping to optimize things as they move forward and want to do it the right way.

If you don’t have the funds and are on a tighter budget then it makes sense to replace the pool pump motor rather than the whole pump.

2. Replacement Time And Effort

You will have to look at how much time it’s going to take to swap out the part.

The pool pump is going to be a much harder replacement because you are going to have to take out the entire part and then optimize the new one too.

This is not going to take much longer but it is enough time to be a factor.

If you are swapping out the pool pump motor, this will also take time but it might be easier since everything else has been optimized to your pool in that setup.

3. Energy Use

How much energy is going to be used by the pool pump once it has been set up?

In general, the new pool pump is going to be far more energy-efficient. On the other hand, if you take the time to replace the pool pump motor, the pool pump itself is still going to be aged.

This means it is not going to save as much energy as the newer replacement would.

For those who are looking to reduce their energy bills, it is best to replace the whole pool pump rather than just the motor.

Look into the difference in cost when it comes to your energy bills. It will be a noticeable difference over time and something to look into.

4. Lifespan

When you swap out the entire pool pump, you are going to be getting a fresh start.

This means it is going to last longer and you are not going to have to worry about it fading as much as you would with the older pump housing.

This is an important detail for those who might be saving money right now. It will come back to haunt you later.

The lifespan is much shorter on the pool pump when you change the pool pump motor. The rest of the pool pump is still going to be old.

Final Thoughts

Should you replace the pool pump motor or the whole pump?

It’s best to replace the whole pump but it can be more expensive and require more time. However, replacing the whole pump is more energy-efficient and it will last longer. In comparison, replacing the pool pump motor is cost-efficient but it will not be as long-lasting.

It comes down to your budget and how much you are going to be using the pool pump.

If it is going to be running throughout the year, you do want to replace the whole pool pump. Getting the pool pump to run the right way is critical or you are going to have major repair bills to deal with later too.